The dietary supplement industry is booming, but one group stands out as the primary consumer: women. According to several market studies, women are the largest buyers of supplements, significantly influencing the way companies develop and market these products. This has led to some unintended consequences, particularly when it comes to the nutritional needs of men. Many supplements are designed with women's needs in mind, including recommended daily values (RDVs) based on a typical female caloric intake. This often leaves men, who typically have higher nutrient requirements, feeling that supplements are less effective or beneficial. Here's why.
The Bigger Consumers of Supplements
Research consistently shows that women are more health-conscious and more likely to purchase dietary supplements than men.
Women are more likely to buy supplements for reasons, such as weight management, skin health, hormonal balance, and general wellness.
This significant female market share has a substantial impact on product development. Since women are the dominant consumers, companies naturally tailor their products to meet the needs of this demographic.
RDVs Are Based on a Female Caloric Diet
The RDVs listed on most supplements are designed to meet the average nutritional needs of a person on a 2,000-calorie diet. This caloric baseline is often aligned more closely with female energy requirements than male. Women typically require fewer calories than men—around 1,800 to 2,200 calories per day, depending on factors like age and activity level. In contrast, men often need more calories, usually in the range of 2,500 to 3,000 calories per day, especially if they are physically active or looking to build muscle mass.
The RDVs for vitamins, minerals, and other nutrients are therefore often insufficient for men, who may need 20-30% more of certain nutrients such as protein, magnesium, and certain B vitamins. For instance, while the RDV for protein is based on a female's needs, men generally require more to support their larger muscle mass and higher testosterone levels.
Men’s Higher Nutritional Needs
Men typically have higher protein, calorie, and mineral needs due to greater muscle mass and a faster metabolism. They also produce more testosterone, a hormone that plays a crucial role in muscle synthesis, energy levels, and overall health. For example, men may need more zinc, which supports testosterone production, or more calcium and magnesium to maintain strong bones and muscles. However, many supplements are formulated with a focus on meeting the nutritional gaps of women, and they might not provide adequate levels of these essential nutrients for men.
Men Don’t Find Supplements as Beneficial
Given that most supplements are designed around the average female diet and nutritional needs, men often find that these products don’t provide them with the desired benefits. This can lead to a perception that supplements are ineffective or not worth the cost, especially when the doses don’t meet their higher physiological demands.
A Lack of Incentive
From a business perspective, supplement companies have little incentive to adjust these formulas to cater more specifically to men. With women being the dominant buyers, the focus remains on addressing their needs. Supplements tailored to men are available, but they represent a smaller market share. The male supplement market is less profitable compared to the female segment, which covers a broader range of health issues like fertility, skincare, and weight loss, driving constant product innovation.
As long as women continue to drive the bulk of supplement sales, manufacturers are likely to focus their efforts on formulations that align with female dietary needs, leaving men to either search for gender-specific products or feel underwhelmed by the offerings on the market.
Conclusion
In summary, women’s dominance in the supplement market has a profound impact on product formulation, with RDVs often based on a female’s caloric intake and nutrient needs. This leaves men, who generally require more of certain nutrients, underserved by many mainstream supplements. Until the male consumer base grows, companies have little incentive to alter their formulations, making it essential for men to seek out products specifically designed for their nutritional needs.
Mantra Men's Club
Health, Wellness & Beauty Supplements created for Men.